SITREP #9: They Chose To Go
Subject: Remembrance Day
I wanted this to go out after the service.
I have been carrying a mixture of sadness, pride and anger around all morning, and I did not want to put a word of it on a page until the minute had been and gone.
The minute has passed now, so here it is.
All three of those feelings are about the same men and women. Sadness for what they went through. Pride in what they chose. And anger, a fair amount of it, that their remembrance is being smashed up by the absolute epitome of cowards.
What they actually were
I think we have heard the word ANZAC so many times that it has gone soft on some. It has become a brand, a long weekend, a bumper sticker. So I'd like the opptinuity to put some weight back into it for those that may need it.
Australia in 1914 was a country of about 4.9 million people. From that, 416,809 men enlisted for the First World War. That is 38.7% of every male aged between 18-44 in the entire country.
Not 38% of the ones who felt like it. 38.7% of all of them.
60,284 of them died before they were discharged. More than 155,000 were wounded, gassed or shell-shocked, many of them more than once. Of everyone who got on a ship and went, the casualty rate was 64.8 per cent, which the Australian War Memorial records as among the highest of the entire war.
Nearly two out of every three. Think about what that means for a street, a footy club, a shearing shed, a school year.
And one day in particular. On 19 July 1916, at a place called Fromelles, more than 5,500 Australians became casualties in a single day. Around 2,000 were killed. It is believed to be the greatest loss by a single division in 24 hours in the whole war.
One day. One division. More Australians than live in a lot of our country towns.
That is who the stones are for.
And here is the part that gets me
They were not made to go.
Under the Defence Act, the government could not compel an Australian to serve overseas. He had to volunteer. And when the casualty lists got so long that the Prime Minister wanted to change that, he had to ask the country for permission.
He asked twice. 28 October 1916. 20 December 1917.
Australia said no twice.
Read those dates again and think about where we were. Gallipoli had already happened. Fromelles had already happened. Pozières had already happened. Everybody knew exactly what they were sending men into, because the telegrams had been arriving for two years.
And in the middle of all of it, the country voted not to force anybody.
Which means every single bloke who went over the side of a boat at Gallipoli, every bloke who went over the bags at Pozières, every bloke on the list at Fromelles, put his hand up. Knowing. He was not dragged there. He chose it.
That is the pride part. That is what I cannot get past. A whole generation of volunteers, from a country of less than 5 million, who went anyway.
What I reckon they were actually fighting for
People argue about this, and they should. That is sort of the point.
But here is where I land. Whatever was going on in the heads of generals and politicians, the blokes in the mud were mostly fighting for the man on their left and the man on their right, and for the idea that back home there was a country where you sorted your arguments out with a vote and a blue at the pub, not with a rifle.
So when people say the ANZACs fought for our freedom, I think the freedom they are talking about is a lot more specific and a lot less fluffy than it sounds. They fought for a country where you can disagree with your neighbour as loudly as you like, and he still has to live next door to you in the morning, and nobody's house gets burnt down over it.
You can protest. You can boo. You can vote the other way. You can write a letter to the paper calling me an idiot.
What you do not get to do is take it out on the stones.
Which brings me to the cowards
Over the weekend, somebody climbed on the Cleveland cenotaph, 106 years old, and broke the pillar off the top of it. It was lying in pieces on the ground on Sunday morning. On Monday, a ute was driven into the Hervey Bay RSL flagpole three times. They could not get it fixed in time, so Hervey Bay held their service today under a bent flagpole.
A cenotaph in Tasmania was pushed off its base in January. RSLs in Melbourne were sprayed on Anzac Day, including a memorial stone with the names of the dead on it. A 100 year old memorial in Beaufort was graffitied with "death to the ADF". The memorial rotunda in Kingaroy had the render stripped off it last month.
Every one of those things happened at night, or to something that cannot move, or to men who have been dead for a century. None of it was done in daylight to anybody who could answer back.
That is the definition of cowardice. Not a difference of opinion. Not a political act. Cowardice. Picking the one target in the entire country that is guaranteed not to hit you back.
I want to say something else about this, because it matters.
In the two Queensland cases, police have not alleged any political motive at all. They say one was a young bloke who was drunk and climbed on it. The other man has been charged with wilful damage and a couple of other things. Both have been charged, neither has been to court, and I am not going to pretend to know more than that.
A lot of people decided within a day that Cleveland was an ideological attack. It might turn out that way. Going on what the police have actually said, it probably will not.
And I think that is worse, not better.
Because it means it was not even conviction. It was not somebody who believed something so strongly they were willing to be arrested for it. It was carelessness. It was a Saturday night and a stupid idea and something 106 years old that did not survive it.
60,000 men did not come home so that a monument to them could be knocked over by somebody who will not remember doing it.
We here at Weight of War are not going to join in the guessing about who did what and why. Whoever it was, and whatever was in their head, the act is the same and the word for it is the same.
What a memorial is actually for
I need to explain this to the people who think a cenotaph is just a lump of rock with a list on it.
For a lot of veterans, a memorial is the only place where the thing can get said without having to be said.
You do not have to explain yourself standing at a cenotaph. You do not have to find the words, or watch somebody's face change when you find them, or work out how much of it the person in front of you can handle. You just stand there and the stone does the talking for you.
For blokes who are not good at asking for help, and there are a lot of us, that is not nothing. That is sometimes the only conversation they have all year.
So when you break one, you are not vandalising a council asset. You are taking away one of the very few places where a bloke who cannot talk about it can go and not talk about it, in the one spot where not talking about it is allowed.
RSL Tasmania said something after theirs was pushed over that I have not been able to shake. They called cenotaphs "memory made visible", and said the job was "not simply to repair the cenotaph, but to reaffirm what it stands for".
That is exactly it.
What I want from us
Not a list of demands. Just what I think.
Turn up. The services are run by volunteers, most of them older than us, and the only thank you any of them want is a bigger crowd next year. Go. Take your kids.
Put your name on your opinions. If you believe something strongly enough to act on it, believe it strongly enough to do it in daylight, with your face showing, to someone who can argue back. That is the standard those blokes set. Anonymous, at night, against something that cannot move, is the exact opposite of everything we stood still for this morning.
Disagree properly. Argue with me. Argue with the government. March if you want to march. That is the thing they bought for us and it is a shame to waste it. Just leave the stones out of it, from whichever direction you are coming.
And check on your mates today. Remembrance Day sits heavier on some people than they will ever tell you. The ones who go quiet are the ones worth ringing.
If today has been a heavy one, Open Arms is 1800 011 046. Free, confidential, twenty-four hours, for veterans and families. Emergencies are 000.
One last thing
A 108 years ago this morning, the guns on the Western Front stopped. Men who had been trying to kill each other for 4 years stood up in the quiet and did not know what to do with their hands.
Everything we have had since, including the right to have a loud public argument about what their monuments mean, exists because of what they did and what they paid for it.
They chose to go. Twice over, as a country, we refused to make anybody.
The least we can do is not knock over the rocks with their names on them.
On 5 December I will put the vest back on and carry it the other way, with anyone who wants to come. But that is a different SITREP.
Today was just the minute. I hope you got to stand in it.
Lest we forget.
Figures on enlistment, casualties and the conscription referendums are the Australian War Memorial's. Details of the recent damage reflect what police and officials had publicly stated as at 11 November 2026. Charges are allegations and none of these matters had been before a court at the time of writing.
Prepared by Weight of War Ltd. Weight of War Ltd is a registered Australian charity and a public company limited by guarantee (ABN 44 698 550 999, ACN 698 550 999) working in Australian veteran mental health and re-purposing.




Comments